Quick Read
If you need to charge extra fees on Shopify, whether for deposits, warranties, eco-fees, or service add-ons, it’s important to choose the right app. Not all apps are built the same. After analyzing the top product fee apps, Magical Product Fees stands out as the best due to its seamless Shopify POS integration, advanced customization, and no-code setup. Unlike other apps that require manual adjustments or coding, Magical Product Fees makes fee management effortless.
Magical Product Fees is the Best Shopify App for Fees
Adding extra fees to Shopify products can be frustrating. Some apps lack POS integration, require technical setup, or clutter your checkout with fees listed as separate products. We’ve reviewed the top Shopify fee apps, and Magical Product Fees is the best choice for merchants who want a simple, effective solution.
Magical Product Fees supports fixed-price and percentage-based fees, offers advanced customization (location-based, cart-based, and payment-method-based fees), and works seamlessly with Shopify POS for in-store transactions. Unlike competitors that require coding or display fees as separate products, it ensures a clean and transparent checkout experience.
Other apps like UpCharge, Canteen, Pfand, and CHARGIFY offer fee management but come with drawbacks like manual setup, missing features, or a lack of checkout clarity. Magical Product Fees provides the best combination of ease of use, transparency, and customization, making it the top choice for Shopify merchants. Try it free for 14 days and streamline your fee management today!
Video Explainer
In this 30-second video, I compare the top Shopify product fees apps and explain why Magical Product Fees is the best app for most stores.
What are the Top Apps for Product Fees on Shopify?
1. Magical Product Fees: The Best Shopify App for Managing Product Fees Effortlessly
Pricing: Starts at $9.99/month with a 14-day free trial. Growth Plan at $12.99/month for Shopify Plus users.
Magical Product Fees makes fee management effortless, offering a no-code setup, advanced customization, and seamless integration with Shopify POS.
- Easy to install with a quick onboarding process
- Supports both fixed-price and percentage-based fees
- Advanced fee customization with location, payment method, and cart-based fees
- Works seamlessly with Shopify POS for in-person transactions
- Display fees clearly on product pages, cart, and checkout
- No coding is required. Merchant-friendly setup.
Reviews for Magical Product Fees are positive, with users frequently praising the app’s support team and functionality as top reasons why merchants love it.
“The technical support provided by the team is remarkably prompt and efficient. Their assistance in setting up our store and POS integration was amazing!” -Beau Dégât Bièrerie de Quartier
“This is the only app that lets me charge one-time fees like deposits. Out of 50 Shopify apps, this is my favorite!” -Duurzaam leasen
Streamline your fee management, improve transparency, and boost revenue with Magical Product Fees. Try it free for 14 days!
2. UpCharge: Surcharges & Fees
Highly Customizable, But Lacks POS Integration
Pricing: Starts at $9.99/month with a 14-day free trial. Free for development stores.
UpCharge offers extensive customization, allowing merchants to apply unlimited product fees with both fixed-price and percentage-based options.
- Supports an unlimited number of product fees
- Allows both fixed-price and percentage-based fees
- Offers extensive customization options
- Provides helpful documentation and video guides
However, UpCharge comes with key limitations that may impact the checkout experience and in-person sales.
- No POS integration, so in-store purchases require manual adjustments
- Fees appear as separate products, which can clutter the cart and confuse customers
- Limited checkout compatibility as it doesn’t work with direct checkout
Accumulating up to 125 reviews, UpCharge stands strong with 91 five star reviews for an overall rating of 4.1 out of 5. With 7 years of service, customers for this app rave about the support and functionality of the app.
“Love this app! Perfect for our cart fees. Customer service and support is top-notch and amazing!” -Planet Tone
“Works really well, lots of options and features to set up your service fees.” -Reclaim Music Group
While UpCharge offers strong customization, it lacks key features for a seamless Shopify experience. Magical Product Fees provides:
- Direct Shopify POS integration for effortless in-store fee management
- Clear fee display on product pages, cart, and checkout with no extra products cluttering the cart
- Advanced fee customization based on location, payment method, and cart value
- A streamlined setup with no technical expertise required
For a POS-friendly, easier-to-use alternative with robust customization, Magical Product Fees is the better choice.
3. Canteen
A Fee Management App with POS Integration, but Requires Coding Knowledge
Pricing: $9.99/month with a 14-day free trial.
Canteen provides Shopify merchants with a rule-based fee builder, making it a solid choice for those needing POS integration and compliance with legal deposit requirements.
- Works with Shopify POS for seamless in-person fee application
- Rule-based fee builder for customized charge setups
- Supports per-quantity or one-time fees
- Integrates with Zapiet (for local delivery) and Recharge (for subscriptions)
- Helps businesses comply with legal deposit requirements
However, Canteen comes with challenges that may make setup and customization difficult for some merchants.
- No onboarding support, so setup can be challenging
- Requires HTML and CSS knowledge as fees won’t display properly without coding
- No percentage-based fees, which leads to limited flexibility for variable charges
- Fees appear as separate products in the cart and may confuse customers
With 25 reviews for an overall rating of 4.5 out of 5, customers using Canteen do express how responsive the support is and how great the app works.
“We love this app. It’s 100% what we were looking for. Easy to install and use.” -Ocean Beer
“Simply great! Solved all our problems for very little money. The support is also nice.” -Candyrbands
While Canteen offers POS integration and supports legal deposit fee compliance, it comes with notable limitations. Magical Product Fees provides:
- User-friendly setup without HTML or CSS knowledge required
- Supports both fixed and percentage-based fees
- Fees display clearly in the cart and checkout, without cluttering the product list
- Better onboarding support with a quick installation with a smooth learning curve
For merchants looking for a hassle-free, no-code solution with advanced customization, Magical Product Fees is the better choice.
4. Pfand – Deposit & Cart Fee: Enforces Fee Collection but Lacks Transparent Display
Pricing: $6.32/month with a 7-day free trial.
Pfand helps merchants enforce mandatory and optional fees, making it a useful tool for businesses that need to comply with EU regulations and Shopify POS transactions.
- Works with Shopify POS for in-person transactions
- Supports both optional and mandatory fees
- Allows country-based fee rules for compliance with EU regulations
- Enables both fixed and percentage-based fees
- Prevents customers from manually removing fees from their cart
Despite its compliance-focused features, Pfand has some drawbacks that may impact usability and transparency.
- Fees appear as products in the cart, potentially confusing customers
- Hiding fees requires coding knowledge and raises transparency concerns
- Setup guides and FAQs are not user-friendly, making onboarding difficult
- Demo store lacks clear examples, making it hard to evaluate the app
Also with a perfect overall rating of 5 out of 5, Pfand – Deposit & Cart Fee’s 15 reviews all express how great the customer support is and how great the app works.
“Great app, great support. Hassle-free installation in minutes. Saved me tons of time.” -Brouwerij Troost
“Superb customer support for customization. Fixing happened within minutes, not days.” -Furnirent
While Pfand offers strong fee enforcement and compliance-based pricing, it comes with drawbacks in user experience and transparency. Magical Product Fees provides:
- Clear and intuitive fee display without listing fees as separate products
- A no-code setup that doesn’t require merchants to manually edit themes
- Seamless onboarding and documentation for an easier learning curve
- Advanced customization with location-based, payment-based, and cart-based fee rules
For merchants seeking a user-friendly, transparent, and customizable fee solution, Magical Product Fees is the better choice.
5. CHARGIFY Surcharge & Order Fee – Affordable but Lacks Customization
Pricing: Starts at $2.99/month or $29.99/year (save 16%) with a 7-day free trial.
CHARGIFY is an affordable option for merchants looking to apply surcharges at the cart level with basic customization options.
- One of the most affordable product fee apps available
- Supports both fixed and percentage-based fees
- Applies fees to the entire cart for streamlined surcharge management
- Allows merchants to customize surcharge conditions based on cart total
However, CHARGIFY has limitations that may restrict flexibility and transparency for some businesses.
- No product-level fees as the app only applies fees at the cart level
- Lacks advanced customization with fewer options for fee conditions
- No demo store or documentation, so it’s unclear how the app functions before installation
- No merchant reviews yet, so it’s difficult to assess reliability and support
While CHARGIFY offers a low-cost solution for basic surcharge management, it lacks flexibility and transparency. Magical Product Fees provides:
- More customization options, including per-product, cart, and location-based fees
- Seamless integration with Shopify POS, allowing fees for in-person sales
- Detailed onboarding support and documentation for an easier setup
- A proven track record with merchant feedback and app reliability
For merchants needing a feature-rich, customizable fee solution with strong support, Magical Product Fees is the better choice.
Real-Life Experience
“It’s essential for Shopify merchants to care about disclosing product fees if they care about transparency and trust with their customers. Clear communication of fees eliminates surprises during checkout and fosters customer satisfaction and loyalty.
I personally find it infuriating when I’m hit with hidden costs at the checkout process that were not made clear on the product page. It really feels like the merchant is trying to pull one over on me and it’s a great way for me to never visit that store ever again. Cell phone companies have done this to me in the past, which leaves me feeling weary of hidden fees.
Product fees also ensure accurate cost recovery and profitability, while offering flexibility in pricing strategies based on customer segments and market conditions.
By generating additional revenue streams through value-added services, merchants can enhance the customer experience and increase their average order value.
A common fee I have come across in my shopping are international custom fees and I have always found it helpful when those fees are mentioned explicitly with instructions on how I can avoid them through orders over a specific dollar amount.
Complying with mandatory fees demonstrates legal responsibility and protects businesses. Remember, product fee relevance depends on the business type, but it is crucial for transparency, profitability, and building customer trust as a Shopify merchant.”
– Saad Khalid, Shopify App Expert
Key Takeaway
The best Shopify app for product fees is Magical Product Fees. It offers a seamless, no-code setup, direct Shopify POS integration, and advanced customization options like location-based and cart-based fees, without cluttering checkout with extra products. Unlike competitors that require coding, manual adjustments, or lack key features, Magical Product Fees makes fee management effortless and transparent.
Magical Product Fees
The Magical Product Fees app is a fast and easy way to build, customize, and attach fees to products or entire orders.